Forum: base
Page 20585
Subject: My write up of the top 20 players in 2021


  Posted by: Seattle Zen - [301361318] Wed, Mar 24, 2021, 18:11

I alluded to this project I undertook back before Thanksgiving. I have dreamed of winning the lotto and retiring to a life of a fantasy baseball tout. I like writing up my draft rationales so I thought maybe I could combine my pre-season draft prep with a writing assignment.

Let me tell you, this was time consuming. I commend the real pros, it's a lot of work. There are some statements in these blurbs that are obviously now out of date but rather than go back and edit I thought I would leave those in there as it is also a snapshot in time.

First Round RIBC preview 2021 Nov. 25, 2020

I sit here in quarantine by order of my eldest daughter for she will not come to Thanksgiving otherwise. What better way to kill time but to start fantasy baseball research? For all we know at this juncture, there will be no spring training games meaning that everything we know about fantasy year 2021 is already in place. I think I will look at the ridiculously loaded top 20 players and try to predict who will thrive and who will disappoint in 2021.

I will place them in alphabetical order at first, then reveal how I think they will place at the end of the season. The stats are from the 2020 season.

Acuna Jr. .406/.581 46/29/8 .413 wOBP 29.7% K 18.8% BB 159 wRC+
He put up these great numbers after a slow start. He slashed .152/.243/.212 in July and went crazy thereafter. When he hits the ball, it goes far! Fifteen singles, 11 doubles and 14 homers. His ISO after July was .400. He strikes out a lot but he walks a ton. He runs very well, eight for nine steal attempts. He was just twenty one last year and had a 41 homer, 37 steal season, generally considered the top pick coming into 2020. He hit the ball harder and walked a lot more as a 22 year old. He has a very strong argument to be the consensus top pick for the second year in a row.

Bauer 1.73/0.79 5 wins 12.33 K/9
Back in March I ran to the library to grab some books to read while we battened down the hatches and I came across The MVP Machine. This book captivated me, I learned a lot about Driveline, a small but very successful outfit here in western Washington that has improved the performance of quite a few major league arms. What most surprised me was how inventive Trevor Bauer and his father have been. They used some very expensive cameras combined with some unique practices to create a process of inventing and improving Trevor’s pitches. I remember reading about Trevor back in 2012 as a Dback, how his unorthodox training methods rubbed management the wrong way and led to his surprising trade to Cleveland. I generally root for iconoclasts so I rooted for Trevor’s success. This book showed that he was far more a trailblazer than I had known. All of that said, it is for the best that I do not have a Twitter account because from what I have gathered in the past few years, Trevor is also a narcissist and a nasty troll with few if any admirable traits outside of his ability to throw a baseball.
But should you draft him in the first round? Well, last season he was lights out! Why? Looking at his velocity, it has been remarkably consistent, his fastball was 93.8 last season and his been between 93.6 and 95 his whole career. He stopped throwing his changeup all together and slightly increased his fastball usage. It looks like his K% went up because he got more people to swing and miss at pitches in the zone. His fastball was lights out last year as well as in 2018. I am trying my best to break down Bauer’s pitches in a way he would himself, but it would also be much easier to simply eyeball his standard stats and point out that he has had only two good seasons, his first six seasons and 2019 his ERA did not get below 4.18. He finally got his K/9 to 10 in 2017 and it has stayed up there since, but in 2017 & 19 he gave up a lot of home runs and his FIP said he deserved most of his poor numbers. He is an enigma to forecast. He is a 4+ ERA and has a poor WHIP for his career but he has had two outstanding seasons. I’m sure there are many of you who drafted him high in 2019 and still feel the burn marks he left. You can rest assured that he is trying harder than probably any other player to study his pitches and to diagnose what may be going wrong, but that didn’t stop his 2019 stinker. I would be leery to draft him in the top 20 for 2021.

Bellinger .333/.455 33/30/6 .337 wOBP, .245 BABIP, 114 w RC+
Cody is the toughest player on this list to forecast. He broke the forecast model the last four years and this could be his fifth in a row. Let’s look year by year at what two well regarded forecasts predicted for CB and what he actually produced. 2017 – No one really saw Cody coming. One popular publication did not even have a MLB prediction for him, the other gave him a 314/465 13 HR, 32 R, 38 RBI, 2 SB line. What did he actually do? .352/581 39 HR, 87, 97, 10. And probably was the number one reason fantasy owners won their league that year. 2018 – the touts correctly predicted some regression. 1) .349/.521 36, 94, 103, 13. 2) .329/.509 37, 93, 103, 10. They were too optimistic as he disappointed his owners with a .343/.470 25, 84, 76, 14. 2019 – the tarnished and tattered touts, chastened by their wishful thinking figured Cody’s 2018 was his new normal so they gave him a bit of an uptick 1) .347/.487 27, 83,85, 16. 2) .348/.484 27, 82, 87, 12. Wrong again, Cody went yard twenty more times than they thought giving him a SLG 125 points higher. .406/.629 47, 121, 115, 15 MVP! Oh, wow, the touts exclaim, I KNEW you were better than 2018, I’ll draft you in the top 6 or so going into this new decade. For the counting stats, I will use rates per PA for the predictions and results. 1) .378/.581 HR .065, R .168, RBI .165, SB .022. 2) .367/.562 HR .067, R .153, RBI .176, SB .017. Cody is all “Nah!” Career lows .333/.455 HR .049, R .136, RBI .123, SB .024. Well, I will say one thing about CB, he is a very consistent base stealer. A full season will see him steal somewhere in the teens. In 2017, 19 & 20 Cody’s slugging % was at least one hundred points away from his forecast. Last year his splits were real pronounced. v. lefties .301/.365 .294 wOBP, 86 wRC+. v. righties .350/.504, .360 wOBA, 129 wRC+. Not so pronounced in 2019: v. L .398 wOBP 150 wRC+. v. R .423 wOBP, 167 wRC+. Even more pronounced in 2018: v.L .297 wOBP, 88 wRC+. v. R .369 wOBP, 137 wRC+. I only bring up his splits because he plays for the Dodgers and they very well may not continue to trot him out there against lefties if he struggles against them in 2021. As you saw in the post season, they platoon some real good bats. I’m not going to anoint CB as the 21st Century bat version of Bret Saberhagen and assume he will bounce back because it is an odd year. With the chance of losing at bats, I can’t draft him in the top 20.

Betts .366/.562 47/39/10 .390 wOBP, .298 BABIP
This guy is good and it doesn’t matter which field is home or which league. He is an even better overall player than just fantasy as he has been second to only Trout since he’s been up in the Bigs. He stole 10 bases last year, an average of .040 per plate appearance. Give him 700 plate appearances, and there are few batters more likely to get to 700, and he will steal 28 at that pace. Twenty eight steals with a .900 OPS and his R/RBI and his numbers look just like Tatis Jr. But you have to think that Betts has the higher floor. Strong argument for each of them. Top 10.

Bichette .328/.512 18/23/4 .353 wOBP, 128 PA, 4%BB, 125 wRC+, .352 BABIP
I’m skeptical AF of this Baby Bichette being on this list. He hurt his knee after playing in just 14 games, but he was crushing at that point – 1.063 OPS. However, the kid DOES NOT WALK. He has a very poor walk rate and has to hit over .300 just to get his OBP up to average. He has speed and stole 32 bases in AA in 2018. Just eight MLB steals so far. To justify taking BB in the top twenty, he would have to steal over 40 bases and slug .550+. That’s not going to happen. Twenty steals and a 800 OPS is a good shortstop but not a top twenty player.

Bieber 1.63/0.87 8 wins 14.20 K/9
Dominating performance. Easily won the Cy Young. But unlike Trevor Bauer, he’s never had a poor season. He’s taken three steps up, way up. Hey, I know this pattern: A; A+1; A+2: what is next? There is no up from here, well, I guess a whole season of A+2 would be a step up. There have been very few full seasons of 1.63 ERA. I can’t find a flaw. Pitchers, though… they can take HUGE steps backwards for no apparent reason. Jack Flaherty was rated right alongside Bieber coming into 2020, Pat Corbin, too. Neither of them were hurt and they disappointed. This is not sabermetrical, but the Baseball gods may simply smite Shane out of whimsy. He deserves his first round status.

Cole 2.84/0.96 7 wins 11.59 K/9 14 HR
I didn’t realize Cole and Bauer were UCLA teammates taken number 1 and 3 in the draft. Because Bauer is Bauer, they didn’t really get along. Cole is the stud thoroughbred and Trevor has to work feverishly to get the most from his donkey body. He has had three great seasons in a row. When you have that K rate and a WHIP below 1.00 and your season was considered a bit of a disappointment, you must be either Pedro Martinez, Maddox or the Big Unit. He gave up nearly a league high 14 homers. A little regression to the mean in the HR department and his ERA will go back to 2.20. He has amazing command. I like him to have a great 2021 and be a top ten player.

Darvish 2.91/0.96 8 wins 11.01 K/9
My all time favorite Persian-Japanese baseball thrower. He turns thirty five this season coming off his best season ever. It looks like it was his best because he nearly eliminated homers, he had his best walk rate ever and he didn’t get hurt. Yet I have the feeling that had this been an entire season, he would have ended up with 165 IP by the end of August, had given up 15 taters in six weeks after the 4th of July and got hurt. He has to have the most number of pitches in baseball. He started throwing his slider 45% of the time in 2019 and stuck with that last season. He jumped his curveball usage up to 15% last year which is where his fastball usage has sunk to, 15%. His fastball velo was at a career high last year, up to 96 MPH. He also uses my favorite pitch, the split fingered fastball 5% of the time. Maybe getting away from his fastball and using all of his pitches, they are all plus offerings, finally unlocked the key to his success. But I just don’t trust the guy and I suspect the Cubs will be out of the playoff picture early and might want to trade him. Just listen to myself, I dive into the numbers, find really good news about a player whom I have an affinity for and I come back with a “I don’t trust him” and a “they might trade him”. Why am I even spending time doing this if that is my knee jerk reaction? Yes, I think he deserves to be a top 20 pick but I wouldn’t blame someone for taking Anthony Rendon or Nolan the Rocky instead.

deGrom 2.38/0.96 4 wins 13.76 K/9
Damn, this dude has been consistent and a work horse. I don’t think I have ever drafted him or watched him, his small market squad just doesn’t get him on TV or in the playoffs. His K rate was a career best, his walk and homer rates are so very steady. His fastball just keeps getting faster! From 94 MPH in 2016 it has gone up each year and is now at 99 MPH. Serious smoke! His fastball usage his ticked down as his slider usage has increased. All I can do is look at his career stats and again say, “damn!” He should be a top ten pick.

Freeman .462/.640 51/53/2 .456 wOBP, 187 wRC+
His age 30 year was a career year and was the MVP of the NL. Career best in all three slash lines (.341/.462/.640), walk rate (17.2%) ISO (.299) wOBA (.456) 187 wRC+ and career low K% (14.1%) And the poor kid thought he was going to die losing like 35 lbs to COVID in April! I don’t need to tell you that this didn’t just come out of nowhere, he has been a very steady, solid bat for Atlanta for a long time. You have to expect some regression from his 1.102 OPS, higher than even Mike Trout’s career best. He was the highest ranked player in all of baseball for our format according to ESPN. I imagine he will be taken around pick number 10 and will likely be profitable at that spot.

Harper .420/.542 41/33/8 .400 wOBP 20%BB, .279 BABIP, 151 wRC+
He has always been a much better fantasy asset in our league as he has a career 15% walk rate. In 2020 he upped that to a career best 20.1% but because he no longer hits over 300 his slugging percentage is no longer a threat to lead the league. Bryce has been pretty steady and I think what we have seen is what we will get – his ISO has been .276,.247,.250,.274 but his BABIP has been .356,.289,.315,.279 so if he gets back to league average perhaps he could get his SLG% up a tick. His steals were 4,15,13,8, if he can get his steals into the teens, he should remain top 20 value. He walked more than he struck out making me think he has one of the highest floors in baseball. If you are still haunted by the dud he gave you in 2014, I’ll take him off your hands.

Lindor .335/.415 30/27/6 .324 wOBP, .157 ISO, .280 BABIP, 100 wRC+
I have to be on my toes when it comes to Lindor because I have a serious crush on the young man. His aesthetically pleasing game with his electric smile, it’s like he is the star eyed emoji playing shortstop. But I doubt he is a top 20 player for 2021. He is better in a traditional 5X5 than RIBC. In 2018 only five players had more homers yet his slugging put him at 19th. He has never been exceptional at taking a walk; in past years he made up for that with a higher SLG% and lots of steals. In 2020, his slugging dropped over 100 points while his .335 OBP stayed the same. His BABIP has stayed nearly the same four straight years so don’t look for improvement there. His wRC+ was league average and a career low, same with wOBA. The Indians have made it clear they want to trade him away. Who knows what that would do for his stats. He is in the final year of his contract, some people think that has significance, I don’t. Anyone drafting Lindor above pick #40 is hoping for a huge improvement over 2020.

Machado .370/.580 44/47/6 .391 wOBP 14.6%K, .297 BABIP
Career year for Manny, greatest in all three slashes, first time over 10% walk rate. Also career marks in ISO, wOBA and wRC+. He loves home cooking: .352/.421/.759 ISO .407 wOBA .480, wRC+ 210, another chapter in a career with a 100 point improvement in OPS at home. He was on pace for steals in the teens. He won’t qualify at shortstop in 2021, just third and that may dampen his draft stock. I’m looking for any warning signs and don’t see anything. Coming into his age 28/29 season I can imagine him earning top ten status for a second straight year.

Ramirez .386/.607 45/46/10 .415 wOBP ,294 BABIP .315 ISO
Jose had a great year, finished second in AL MVP voting and earned fifth overall in the player rater. He did have a career best wOBA but not by a ton. His last four seasons he has been one of fantasy baseballs best performers: Of the top 20 wOBA players since the beginning of 2017, Jose is one of ten with at least 300 runs and RBI and has the most steals. I’m trying to find a chink in his armor and I am coming up empty. He has similar home and away splits. Maybe he is a slow starter, his Mar/April and May career splits are a touch lower than the rest, but really, he has been been better than Nolan Arrenado the past four years but drafted after him. He’s a true five category stud and should be drafted as such.

Soto .490/.695 39/37/6 .478 wOBP, 21% BB, 200 wRC+, 196 PA.
Did you catch what a historic hot streak Juan ripped off last year? His 200 wRC+ is the eighth best since 1990. 2001-4 Bonds were the four best, 1994 Jeff Bagwell and Frank Thomas were 205 as was 1998 McGwire. Yes, no Trout. Seems like you need steroids to reach 200. Those of us who watched the 2019 post season saw a preview of what Juan was capable of doing. This kid is so young and has shown ridiculous power for his age, you will be forgiven for thinking that he will continue to improve each year until he turns 28. Truth is, just a slight step back with his bat and he could still be the MVP. He is likely to have a 1.000 OPS and 220+ R/RBI, just like Trout, so what everyone is dying to know is how many steals are we talking here? He stole 6 bases in only 47 games. Twelve steals in a full 2019. If he kept up last years pace, 24 to 25 steals with his OPS would make him the top bat in the league I would suggest. That is why I believe he is the best overall pick.

Story .355/.519 41/28/15 .370 wOBP 117 wRC+
Trevor took a tiny step back with his slash rates of .289/.355/.519. He did have a career high walk rate. His .370 wOBP and 117 wRC+ were right at career averages. He hit second most of the season and that negatively affected his RBI numbers. What really stood out about Story in 2020 was his 15 steals, third best in the league. Is he now a potential 35 steals guy? Because an average year of Story’s bat with 35 steals makes him another Trey Turner, does it not? I think Story is slightly underrated.

Tatis Jr. .366/.562 50/45/11 .392 wOBP, 149 wRC+
“Regression will bring Tatis back to Earth in 2020 so don’t go drafting him in the first round”. The results from the lab says this is a LIE. He basically had the same seasons in 19 & 20 and they are ridiculous. Another handsome face for baseball to market, wild hair and first rate homer celebrations. Fast as the wind on a team that likes to steal. He will be 22 years old for 2021 and for fantasy baseball his competition for best shortstop will be between Trey Turner, Story and himself, for the Future of Baseball title he’s competing against Juan Soto and Acuna Jr. Ah, I may have found a flaw in his game, he struggled against the shift and I don’t know if teams started shifting against him in the second half which damped his results and will continue to do so in 2021. I still think he is a likely a 900+ OPS, triple digits in runs and RBI and 25 or more steals. Top ten all day.

Trout .390/.603 41/46/1 .407 wOBP 164 wRC+ 14.5%BB
Did you realize that Trout has only had one 30/30 year, his rookie campaign? Trout has been remarkably consistent with his bat his whole career. He rarely misses games. His OPS has been within touching distance of 1.000 every year since 2015. Nine straight years of a wOBP over .400. His .390 OB% was his first below .400 since ‘14. Fourth straight SLG% over .600. Because he plays in Anaheim he has only knocked in 100RBI three times and won’t lead the league in runs scored. He does not look like he has started any age related decline and should continue to have a OPS over a thousand and R/RBI over 220. He is possibly the easiest bat to forecast: HOF numbers. But what of steals? He stole 11 bases in 2019 and he was not the top rated player that year. He only stole one last year, giving him a 10.13 score on the RIBC player rater, middle of the first round stuff. He is projected to steal another 10 bases in 2021. There are very few bats that you can count on to give you a 1.000 OPS, but with these young horses stealing 25 or more bases along with a chance of .950+ OPS, Trout is not the number one player in 2021.

Turner .394/.588 46/41/12 .413 wOBP 8.5% BB, 14% K, 157 wRC+
Remember in 2016 when Turner came out of no where and in half a season stole 33 bases while slashing .370/.562? He was taken like fourth or fifth in 2017 with people licking their lips at the thought of 60 steals and this hot bat. I was not a buyer, I’m a little to risk adverse, I stayed away in 2018 & 19, too. But last year he fell to 13th and I took him with my first round pick. What a season! Even though his walk rate is just average, his OB% was a robust .394 because he hit .335. Career high .584 slugging, .253 ISO, career low 13.9% K rate. But a career low steals rate and success rate. I’m not afraid that Troy suddenly got slower, I see a bounce back for him in that department in 2021. His bats skills now really impress me. I suspect a 850 OPS (.350/.500) with 30 or so steals places him in the top five or six bats.

Yelich .356/.430 39/22/4 .343 wOBP, 18.6% bb, 30.8% K, .259 BABIP, 112 wRC+
CY had a terrible ,205 batting average but with his enormous walk rate, he was not a disaster in our league. His walk rate went through the roof because he stopped swinging the bat, he swung at fewer than 35% of all pitches, second lowest in baseball. His batting average was terrible because he struggled to hit fastballs. That is not a sentence you want to hear coming from the player you draft in the first round. He struck out 54% of the time he had a two strike count. Remember when the knock against Yelich was he was a ground ball hitter? His Ks in 2020 are more problematic. He had a career worst BABIP, about a hundred points below his career average, so I expect his batting average will improve somewhat. He was drafted in the top ten in recent years because he combined a high OPS with steals, but in 2020 he only attempted six steals and was caught twice. If he only steals 12 bases in 2021, he will not likely bring top 20 value and predicting steals is really a guessing game for CY.
 
1Seattle Zen
      ID: 301361318
      Wed, Mar 24, 2021, 18:13
2021 RIBC predictions for picks 21-50

Abreu: .370/617 43, 60, 0 7% BB, .350 BABIP, .300 ISO, .411 wOBA, 167 wRC+
The White Sox were the AL surprise of 2020 during the regular season and offseason. They handed the Twins the AL Central at the end of September and then handed the reigns to a drunk dinosaur later in the fall. Tony LaRussa, who handed John McGraw his first managerial loss, will be handing the umpire the Sox line up card filled out with his quill and ink pot. Abreu was the surprise 2020 AL MVP. His season matched his 2014 debut’s rate stats and had the most RBI in baseball. He has been a very steady slugging bat with only 2018 slightly disappointing; you are going to get 100+ RBI from him. His slash lines, though, are a danger to be rather average. His walk rate has hovered between 5.2% and 6.9% the last six years so if he doesn’t hit over .300, he will give you a .325 or .330 OBP like 2018 or 19. His SLG for those years, .473 and .503 were also good but not great. One would imagine his .350 BABIP foretells a decline in his average for 2021 but he does have a surprising .328 lifetime average, better than most slow firstbasemen. While I often think it is lazy to say, “look at two years ago and that’s what he will probably do this year”, it really seems appropriate for Jose. If he knocks in 125 RBI, he will be a good value. If it is just 100, then he will be around the #8 or 9 firstbaseman for the year.

Albies .306/.466 21,19,3, 4% BB, 24% K, .329 wOBA, 103 wRC+
Aussie, Aussie, Aussie, ouch, ouch, ouch! So it seems little Ozzie had a bum wrist most of the year. Even with his hampered hand, he had a nearly identical season with the bat as his 2018, just more Ks. I have to admit that I harbor an unhealthy skepticism of small baseball players and Albies is rather tiny. I will try to put that aside and imagine that going into his age 24 season he could knock 30 balls over the fence. He doesn’t walk much and I don’t follow the Braves enough to know if his 4% walk rate last year was because pitchers were not afraid of him, throwing him everything in the zone or if he bails them out by swinging at all offerings. Over his short career he has two seasons of 350+ OBP, a baseline for a top 50 player in my book. He has one season of .500 SLG. I will give him the benefit of the doubt that his sore wrist sapped his power in 2020 and will imagine he will SLG between 510-550. Get that OBP back to 350 and batting at the top of the Braves lineup you should score 100+ runs. That narrows down his most important variable of his value to steals. He stole 14 and 15 bases in 2018 & 19. If you think he is steal between 18 and 22 bases, he is a top 40 value. If he steals below 9, maybe the Braves think they need to protect his wrist, then he will disappoint you in 2021.

Anderson .357/.529 45, 21, 5. 4.5% BB, .376 wOBA, 143 wRC+ .383 BABIP
Back to back career years from Timmy. When he puts the ball in play, he generally gets on base, he had a ridiculous .399 BABIP in 2019, he seems to have a real knack at that skill as it has given him back-to-back .357 OBP with absurdly low walk rates. He had just 3 3-0 counts in 2020 and 16 in all of 2019. Bryce Harper, on the other hand, had 30 and 64. This allergy to taking a pitch gives him a low floor. The past two years he has hacked at 43-45% of pitches outside of the zone, Vlad Sr. type of approach to hitting but not as much contact. He is not a part of the fly ball revolution, had a career low line drive rate and career high GB% making me think he has a high floor for his batting average but a limitation upon his slugging. Last year 24% of his fly balls went for homers, before that it was between 14-16%. So even though he has slugged over 500 the past two years, I suspect he will be below it in 2021. The more I look at him, the more he resembles Ozzie Albies. And like Ozzie, his steals total is a real difficult stat to forecast, who knows what LaRussa thinks about stealing bases in 2021. Tim has a low floor in three categories – OBP, SLG and RBI. He should score plenty of runs in the high powered Sox offense. If he steals 16 or more bases, he will be a top 40 player again.

Arenado .303/.434 23, 26, 0 .241 BABIP, .308 wOBA, 76 wRC+
Ugh, he had his worst season since he was a rookie in 2013. Coming off a rock solid five year stretch, this was obviously unexpected. He injured his shoulder making a diving stop on a ball in the fifth game of the season and his AC joint bothered him all season. Didn’t need surgery, just rest. That’s the type of news that makes me feel confident that going into his age 30 season he should look a lot more like the Arenado of the previous five seasons. The other news is that Nolan thinks management is awful at their jobs and he is right. But with the contract he has it is very unlikely he can be traded so Mile High home at bats look like they will continue in 2021 (WRONG!) I don’t need to dive deep into his batted ball numbers, I think he will likely produce top 25 numbers and that is without the help of steals. His draft position will be hampered by his poor 2020 performance and fear that his new home stadium will depress his numbers, making him one of my top profit targets of 2021.

Bregman .350/.451 19,22,0 .345 wOBP, 122 wRC+, .254 BABIP. 5 barrels
Perhaps the face of the Stros’ cheating scandal and the ass pitchers and fans wanted to bean the most. I understand that he tweaked his hammy at some point in the season, that may be why he didn’t attempt a stolen base. His 13.3% BB rate was a career low, but damn, that’s still awesome. He did poorly against breaking balls last year, particularly the slider, but in 2018-19 he was elite vs. the slider, so perhaps 2020 was simply a rebuke by the Baseball Gods – how’s that for scientific sabermetrics? Could also be that he would sit on the breaking stuff because he didn’t hear the garbage can ping. Though I don’t think he will hit 40 homers again, he is too talented and young to not have some regression back to his former All-Star status. I suspect that I will have Alex on one of my teams in 2021.

Bogaerts .364/.502 36, 28, 8 .368 wOBP, 130 wRC+
Xander has now had three straight seasons of slugging over .500. Coming into the 2018 season, he looked like Amed Rosario, a ten homer, 15 steals guy. He declined to be limited as such and if not for the Golden Age of fantasy shortstops, he would be more revered. He mashed at cleanup for the Sox in 2019 like Albert Belle .384/.555 33 HR, 110 runs, 117 RBI and 4 steals. It looks like he may not knock in 100 RBI again because the Sox offense is so meager, but his 8 steals in 2020 was an exciting development. If he gets back to stealing 15 or so bases with a .850+ OPS, he will be a top 30-35 player. This is his age 28 season, he’s the face of the Red Sox and does not have a flaw in his game. The only interesting thing I found looking at his stats was in 2019 there was a HUGE difference in his defensive metrics, one site gave him a +8 for the season while another was -20 and slashed his WAR in half.

Buehler 3.44/0.95 1 win .198 BABIP, 10.31 K/9
The way I feel discussing a pitcher who started only eight games last year feels a whole lot different than discussing a batter who had 260+ plate appearances. Buehler’s ERA was not top 50 stuff but his WHIP certainly was. Maybe if he played on a good team he would have had more than one win HA! I am surprised he turns 27 this season, he feels like a sophomore. He gave up 8 homers in his seven games or 1.72/9. That is what happens when 42% of the balls hit were fly balls and 18% of those go over the fence. Still feel like there was a lot of short season variance here, he looked dominant in the Post Season. He had a top five fastball last season, I think his regression will keep him in the top 30.

Castillo 3.21/1.23 11.44 K/9, 0.64 HR/9, .329 BABIP
Luis followed up a great 2019 with a nearly identical 2020. He’s a great groundball pitcher (58%) He somehow manages to keep his fly balls from leaving the park in Cincinnati (12.5% HR/FB) Even though he has elite fastball velocity (97.5 MPH), he throws his change up more than his fastball and that has lead to his great results. He had the fifth best FIP in 2020. I think his elevated BABIP may be why his ERA was above 3.00. He is 28, things are pointing to an even better season in 2021.


Devers .310/.483 32, 43, 0 5% BB, 27% K, .337 wOBA, 109 wRC+
The young kid had a phenomenal age 22 season in 2019. He was a first round pick last year and started real slow, ending up with disappointing numbers. His second half .341/.556 .377 wOBA, 137 wRC+ looked more like the Raphel of 2019. However, he had a career low walk rate and career high strikeout rate that was there for both halves of 2020. He went 8 for 16 on stolen bases in 19 and wisely stopped attempting to steal last year. Oddly for someone with such a low OBP and no steals, he batted second for Boston. He was near the league leaders in RBI last year but that may have been a mirage as he had a 1.019 OPS with men in scoring position. So, if you are the type to look at his second half results and come up with some excuse for his poor first half and want to pencil in 100 runs and RBI, he could be a top 40 bat. If you are leery of a heavy, no steals, can’t take a walk, maybe is disinterested when his team sucks kid, he may just be an average thirdbaseman who doesn’t crack the top 100.

Flaherty 4.91/1.21 10.93 K/9, 3.57 BB/9 3.42 FIP
That ERA is unsightly. He had entered the 2020 season as a 24 year old coming off two excellent seasons, an ERA below 3.00, a tiny WHIP, 10.7 K/9. He really was lighting up the league in the second half of 2019 – 0.91 ERA/0.70 WHIP, 27.6% K-BB%. He was very hyped for good reason. What happened? His fastball went from awesome to not very good – his velocity went down a tick, he threw it right in the middle of the plate and at 44% of his pitches, he throws it too much. His exit velocity was a career high at 90 MPH and he may have actually been lucky last year that his ERA was not worse. A staggering 36% of his batted balls were line drives. That probably won’t happen again. He has an elite slider and should be throwing it a lot more. That simple change would certainly improve his 2021. I am leery. I suspect there will be enough guys counting on a bounce back that I will end up with zero shares.

Gallen 2.75/1.11 10.25 K/9
Um, who in the hell is Zac Gallen? Some bespectacled Dback sans notoriety. His 93 MPH fastball is not fast, but it is very effective. His curveball is elite (.129 wOBA, 45% K rate). He has only thrown for 150 innings in the majors over two seasons. I honestly don’t know what to make of him. Last year his projections suggested an ERA north of 4.00, he has similar projections for 2021. In order to really dive deeper, one would have to know what to make of his minor league innings, I can’t. I will put him below the top 50.

Giolito 3.48/1.04 12.07 K/9, 3.12 FIP
Lucas is legit. He went from the worst pitcher in baseball in 2018 (6.13 ERA, 6.5 K/9) to a top 20 arm 2019-20. His fastball and change up are outstanding. He improved his swing and miss percentage, lowered all of his batted ball outcomes, increased his strike out rate all while his fastball velocity dipped a tick. He combines an elite strikeout rate with a very low WHIP on a team that should win a lot of games. He has the goods for a sub 3.00 ERA.

Glasnow 4.06/1.13 14.28 K/9 2.75 xFIP, 23.4% HR/FB
Wait, wha? Tyler is 6’8”? Let’s cut to the chase, he gave up a lot of homers in 2020. His fastball velocity is top shelf but he leaves it over the middle middle and it goes BOOM. There is a lot of talk about control/command of pitches but most of it deals with being in or out of the strike zone. Not much talk about a guy’s ability to keep the pitch out of the middle of the zone. On a squad as high tech and saber-centric as the Rays, you would think they would address this distressing flaw in the tall guy’s heater. The exit velocity and launch angles are a vicious indictment for a pitch that was pretty good in 2019. He has a great curveball but now that he is a two pitch only guy, batters are not swinging at his curveball as much and waiting on his heater. He has an arm injury history and pitches on a team that will remove you from a start where you have given up one hit, no runs and have thrown only 61 pitches, how are you supposed to win your starts? He could be lights out and then hurt like 2019. He could be throwing up meat and healthy all year like 2020, or stay healthy and have a great season for the first time in his career. This seems like an awfully high spot in the draft to take that chance.

Jimenez .332/559 26, 41, 0 5% BB, 25% K, .373 wOBA, 141 wRC+,
Here’s another age 24 player who doesn’t take a walk or steal bases, speaks Spanish and plays for the Sox, but these are Blanco. Eloy is one of two rising stars in the White Sox outfield, he is the one with the best first name and worst defense. He has never attempted to steal a base in the majors. He doesn’t hit enough fly balls, only 28.5% of his hits were flyballs, but 31% of those went yard. I think those two numbers (and his Statcast velocity) have lead touts to predict that he could hit 40 homers a year. He really needs to hit more flies, last year his OPS on flyballs was 1.855! and a .726 wOBA! Eloy’s key to fantasy stardom relies on his power, if he slugs between 550 and 600, he will also knock in over 100. His OBP is like his defense, you cringe when you see a ball is headed towards him, hoping that he will not screw up and he is at least average. I didn’t realize how similar Eloy and Devers were and I think it’s because Devers gets a lot more hype. For 2021, I would take Eloy.

Judge .336/554 23, 22, 0 8.8% BB, .375 wOBA, 140 wRC+
Aaron is from tiny, insignificant Linden, CA. He was adopted, of course, because the people of Linden are incapable of producing quality athletes of their own… I went to high school nearby and my buddy is their high school wrestling coach. Aaron played tight end and center for their basketball team. I don’t need to remind you about his record breaking rookie year or the fact that he has not approached that level of production again. Like his teammate Stanton, these two godlike freaks of nature spend a lot of time in the shop. I imagine a Star Wars-type scene where Aaron and Giancarlo’s detached heads are on a work bench chatting while an army of dwarfs work on their broken down bodies. I do my best to avoid listening to anything regarding the Yankees so I don’t remember what types of injuries have befallen The Judge, I honestly can’t forecast the likelihood of a full season of health so I am going to focus on his production from 2018-20. Judge had an outstanding 15.3% and 14.3% BB rate in 18 & 19 leading to .392 and .381 OBP. His walk rate fell to 8.8% coupled with a career low batting average of .257 gave him a pedestrian .336 OBP last year. I can understand why Aaron Boone would put a .392 OBP player in the two spot in the lineup but that has limited Judge’s RBI opportunities quite a bit even with the stud LeMahieu batting lead off. Judge came to the plate with the bases empty a lot in 2019 so he ended up with only 55 RBI. I’m looking for splits that might show a weakness, MLB hasn’t decided whether to shift against him or not, the shift doesn’t seem to negatively affect him. He does not have a pronounced weakness at home or the road, v. R or L. He has a very consistent 32% HR/FB rate which is elite. Let’s say he gets to 600+ PA in 2021. And let’s say that last year’s .283 BABIP was unlucky and he gets back to something more like .330. His value may very well rest on what walk rate he generates, is it back to his elite rate in the teens like 18 & 19 or is it in the single digits like last year? I will say that even at 600 PA, a .340 OBP and his new normal .550 SLG will probably generate between 80-90 runs/RBI with little to no steals and that looks like Eloy/Devers territory. And he has only had 600 PA once in his career. His profile is one that draws the risk takers’ attention while scaring the risk adverse. In RIBC where there are no DL slots, I have to knock him towards the bottom of the top 50 at the moment. If we have a Spring Training and he hits some moon shots, I am certain that I will not have to entertain the notion of drafting him as one of you degenerate gamblers will scoop him up early.

Kershaw 2.16/0.84, 9.57 K/9, 3.6 BB%
When a 0.84 is not your career best WHIP, you are headed to the HOF. I do not like the Dodgers and for completely aesthetic reasons, I loath Clayton Kershaw. He reminds me of Dirk Nowitzki and his fuggly knee-cocked, barely jumped off the floor shot that makes you lose your appetite. Clayton’s wind up and delivery are just ugly, herky-jerky yuck. Regardless of how well he keeps players off the bases and from scoring, watching Kershaw pitch is just not as rewarding as just about ANY other pitcher. So you would think I would be elated with his horrendous bad luck in the post season for his career, the way he seems to sink the Dodgers year after year. I don’t, I actually started to feel bad for him and his untimely gopher balls and I do remember plenty of post season successful starts before this year. It was past time for the 800 pound payroll in the room to finally hoist the trophy. I do not have any sabermetrical insights into Kershaw for 2021. He has shown that when he gets on the mound there are few better. He doesn’t have the K rate of the very best starters. His value will derive from how many innings he pitches. How does anyone accurately predict that?

LeMahieu .421/.590 41, 27, 3 .429 wOBA, 177 wRC+
DJ is the type of Yankee that I love in fantasy and angers me in real life. I love his sneaky power and the way he has disrupted their lineup, I hate how the Yankees got such a ridiculous bargain. I would LOVE for the Bombers to let him sign elsewhere and put their eggs in the Gleyber basket. Would HATE it if they sign him to a multi year deal and send Gleyber to the Indians for Lindor! DJ’s wOBA was fourth best overall. Since 2015, he has a .316/.373/.457 slash line. It’s that final slash that has changed so much since coming to the Yanks. He LOVED the Bronx last year - .505/.813 for a Bonds’ like 1.317 OPS. It wasn’t so pronounced in 2019, his slugging % was .459 road, .585 home. So, if he stays with the NYY, I love his outlook for 2021, if he signs someplace with a tough home park like the Giants or someone, that would concern me. Looking at his splits, wow, he hit .505 last year going the opposite way, seven oppo tacos of his ten. You can’t shift him, you can only hope to contain him and maybe the best way to do that is have him sign with the Marlins or the A’s. DJ has elite contact skills, his power bloomed the past two years, and even without steals he is one of the best infield bats in baseball.

Maeda 2.70/0.75 32.3 K%, 4% BB, 3.00 FIP, 24.7 Hard hit %
LOVED this trade for the Twins. Kenta is seriously underrated. He barely walks anyone, strikes out more than most and induces very weak contact. That WHIP will carry your fantasy team. The Twins got him to reduce his fastball from over 40% to just 19% and it went from an average pitch to outstanding. Paired with an elite change up and a very good slider, he was the whole package. With the retirement of Hisashi Iwakuma, Kenta is my current Nihongo speaking 告白 こくはく. His .208 BABIP may go up, but his 18.8% HR/FB will probably go down. I’m loving what being on the Twins does for Maeda and I have him HIGH up on my list.

Marte .340/.430 36, 27, 10 .333 wOBA, 109 wRC+ 4.8% BB, .149 ISO
Starling finally left the Iron City to showcase his speed first for the Dbacks, then in teal for the Marlins. Why is it that I feel perpetually disappointed with him? He has consistently refused to take a walk. He did steal 47 bases in 2016. His only terrible season was 2017. He has a career .450 SLG% and is usually right around that mark. Combine that with 30 steals in today’s market and that is a very good player. It was a very small sample size but his numbers in Miami were pretty bad. Will Mattingly set him loose on the basepaths? Will he get on often enough to make a difference? He took two walks and struck out 22 times as a Marlin. He hit 16 singles, so the fact that he stole five bases in Miami out of 18 times on first, that bodes well. I should shake my unwarranted gloom and pencil him in for a top 50 slot but I suspect his slugging will be below .450 if he stays in Miami.

Merrifield .325/.440 38, 30, 12 4.5% BB, .329 wOBA, 106 wRC+
Whit is all about the steals. You can count on him playing every day, but he is not young, this will be his age 32 season. He had a career low walk rate and BABIP. There is a world of difference between a .350+ OBP and .325. Even more of a difference between stealing 45 and 20 bases. You can forgive a 750 OPS if it comes with 30-40 steals. You need a 800+ OPS if you will only chip in 20 steals as a top 50 pick. He had a pronounced home/away split last year but for his career there is none. He has a very team friendly contract, maybe the Royals should ship him somewhere for a basket of prospects. I’m under the impression that the Royals are still one of the greenest lights for base stealers and a move away would likely hamper his SB totals. So… pros: Very healthy, solid line drive hitter, very fast, steals. Con: Doesn’t walk, few homers so low SLG, may get traded and stops stealing. This is a strange sentence to write but if he gets traded away from Kaufman Stadium, his value will plummet. That risk puts him towards the bottom of this list.

Mondesi .294/.416 33, 22, 24 .305 wOBA, 89 wRC+ 4.7% BB, 30% K, .350 BABIP
Adalberto had his first “full” season and led the majors in steals. Combine his last two years – 161 games, 676 PA, he stole 67 bases. I didn’t realize that last year he was wretched for the first forty games – a .479 OPS. His final 19 - .370/.425/.740 with 6 HR, 14 SB, 22 R, and 16 RBI. What do you take from such a torrid finish? Is that what is possible when he is healthy? Is the only reason he hasn’t struck out 200 times simply because he hasn’t had a season with 600+ PA? He has the most upside of this entire group. He has the ability to steal 65 bases in 2021 and has shown that he could slug 500+. He will always have a low OBP floor. Last year he had a huge home/away and lefty/righty split – Home .378/.563 .398 wOBA, 151 wRC+ .435 BABIP Away - .217/.284 .218 wOBA, 32 wRC+ .270 BABIP. Versus Righties .278/.323 33% K, versus Lefties .345/.698. 20% K. These splits were fall less pronounced in 2018 & 19, may have just been small sample sizes. I’m guessing that over his career when he is hitting the ball well he gets placed at the top or two spot in the lineup and when he is scufflin he’s moved down to seven or eight. A .300/500 with 65 steals is a top 5 finish, a .280/.420 with 40 steals looks like his floor and that is still pretty damn good. I like him a lot.

Nola 3.28/1.08 12.11 K/9, 19.6% HR/FB
Before 2019, I would have had no clue what Aaron’s father’s first name was, but once his older brother Austin started playing for the Mariner’s, I now suspect that it starts with an A. Surely you have noticed that brothers who have the same first letter in their first name are usually following their father. So do you think it’s August? Adolph? Adelbert? Aaron had a very good season which now gives him two. He had a better ERA in 2018, but this year may have been even better overall. He threw his changeup a lot more, he started using it against right handers as well as lefties. His fastball is below league average velocity, but his curveball is so good – 42% swing and miss, that he has an elite strikeout rate regardless. Looking at just his four seam heater, perhaps 2020 he got a little lucky. With no change in pitch or exit velocity, he went from 2019 .269/.509/.376 (BA/SLG/wOBA) to .135/.327/.222. He will turn 28 this season. The Phillies bullpen is garbage so his chances of a lot of wins is small. I like him to stay healthy and strike out a lot of batters but a 3.50/1.25 line is likely, putting him on the edge of a top 50 player.

Ozuna .431/.636 38, 56, 0 .444 wOBA, 179 wRC+ 14.2% BB, .391 BABIP
What a year! The Braves would be insane not to resign him, just look at how much fun Acuña had dancing around with Marcell. Why he won’t repeat: He has had six seasons of OBP between .302 and .328 versus two years with .431 and .378. Those six seasons his slugging was between .383 and .472. His career numbers coming into 2020 were .329/.455 7.5% BB, .183 ISO, .314 BABIP, .336 wOBA, 112 wRC+. Why he should hold his gains: His exit velocity, launch angle, barrel % and hard hit % were all career highs and elite. His 26.5% HR/FB is sustainable. He has learned to take a walk, he has no pronounced difference in his splits, he beats the shift. He didn’t steal a single base for the Braves but he did steal 12 in 2019 for the Cards. His .391 BABIP is unsustainable so he probably won’t have another .444 wOBA but few batters ever have. I like his chances of surpassing his historical projections.

Realmuto .349/.491 33,32,4 .361 wOBA, 121 wRC+
JT had a career year for the Phils but honestly it wasn’t that much out of the ordinary. The past three years have all been pretty similar. He going to be 30 years old this season and he doesn’t know where he will be calling home yet (as expected, re-signed with Phils) He went from a terrible home park to one of the best in Philly in 2019. He exchanged 10% of his batted balls from liners into ground balls last year despite an increase in barrels. He should correct that which should give him a boost in all categories. He kept his slugging up because he had a career best HR/FB% of 23.4%. He had a fairly pronounced LvR split. League average .748 OPS v. righties, 1.091 v. lefties. Hopefully the NL will keep the DH and he can hit against lefties on his days he’s not behind the plate. Well, maybe last year was a fluke because his career numbers has no split whatsoever. Home and away splits, however, were enlightening. Playing at home in Miami was awful for JT, in over 1000 PA, he had a disappointing .292/.384 .279 BABIP, 87 wRC+, .291 wOBA. On the road, he was .327/.442 .319 BABIP, .329 wOBA, 108 wRC+. I could excuse JT if he wanted to take a mental health three day weekend when he travels to south Florida in 2021 to avoid PTSD flashbacks. He should repeat as the number one catcher in 2021 and catcher is the only position, I believe, that has scarcity. The amount of added value to account for that scarcity is left up to the individual user. I probably would not add enough value to JT’s projection to put him in the top 50.

Rendon .418/.497 29, 31, 0 .395 wOBA, 156 wRC+ 16.4% BB, 13.4% K

He had a pretty amazing season for someone who complained about a sore wrist in August, maybe that explains why he had his first sub 500 slugging since 2016. The man consistently avoids striking out, had a career best walk rate and the sixth best OBP in baseball. He has a very high floor, a pretty safe bet for a 900 OPS. His counting stats suffer playing for the Angels and it looks like they have given him a permanent red light – no steals. His contact skills are ridiculous and eerily steady. He only swings and misses 5% of the time, every year. He will hit the ball over 90% of the times he swings at it in the zone. Such consistency, about a safe a bet in the top 50 as you can find.

Robert .302/.436 33, 31, 9 .316 wOBA, 101 wRC+. 32% K rate.
He started so very hot, hitting .354/.415/.542 and a 177 wRC+ before falling apart. In Sept he hit .136/.237/.173. He has a very low OBP floor. 22% swinging strike percentage. He only hits the ball with 61% of his swings. No real reason to walk him, he’ll miss your pitch. How does a Cuban end up with the last name Robert? Last year, when they say he turned 23 in August, he hit 30 homers, scored 108, 92 RBI and 36 steals in 122 games at three levels. He’s a wizard in the field, can he cut his strikeouts down and get his OPS to 750+? He will probably be in the top ten in steals with close to 30. I’m not optimistic he belongs in the top 50.

Scherzer 3.74/1.38 12.3 K/9, .355 BABIP, 14.3% HR/FB
First time we have not seen a 2 as the first digit of a Max ERA in a long time. Having owned Max in a keeper league for many years, I have memories of tough stretches that would take his ERA from the peak of Mount Olympus and bring it back to the realm of mortals but something seems different this time. He will turn 37 midway through the 2021 season and you have to suspect that 2600 IP may start taking a toll. His exit velocity was a career high, his fastball velocity is going down. His curveball was awful last year - .471 batting average and .706 SLG. His changeup wasn’t very good, either - .328/.466. His fastball has gone from elite to average – 2018 wOBA .254, 2019 . 306, 2020 .366. And 56.2% of the hits off his fastball were hard hits. 34% LD rate. In 2017, his batting average against was .177, it has steadily gotten worse, now .266. Slugging - .319, now .424. He really needed that high strike out rate to keep him from a bigger disaster. Coming into 2020, not many saw age related decline – I saw forecasts of 2.71/1.04. I fear we have missed his age related decline and it may rapidly accelerate in 2021.

Seager .358/.585 38, 41, 1 .394 wOBA, 151 wRC+ NLCS and World Series MVP
What a way to end such a great bounceback season. It’s easy to forget that he was only 21 years old when he debuted in 2015 and crushed a .986 OPS in 27 games. Age 22 and he wins the NL Rookie of the Year. He had TJ surgery in 2018 and wasn’t healthy in 2019, either. This year he crushed, literally, he had the fourth highest hard hit rate in baseball. There are reasons to believe he could have an even better 2021 in addition to his ridiculous post season. He had a career low walk rate. He could improve his HR/FB rate as his hard hits start going over the fence. His BABIP of .309 should be better for someone with his exit velocity. He has the tools to go .370-380/600 & 220 R/RBI. That’s top 25 stuff. He has every incentive to have a career year as he will be looking at signing a $300+ million contract in 2021. He could also get hurt and look like the Corey of 2019. I am betting on the big numbers.


Tucker .325/.512 33, 42, 8 .349 wOBA, 125 wRC+ 8%BB
I really had no idea Kyle could do this. I guess his minor league stats should have clued me in. Last year only 11 players stole more bases than Tucker and of the players with eight or more steals, only six had a higher slugging. In 2019 at triple A, he hit 34 homers, stole 30 bases and slashed .354/.555. In 2018 it was .400/.590 24 and 20. Why were the Stros giving at bats to Josh Reddick? His walk rate was double digits in AAA so he may be trending towards that in the Bigs. He’s going to be 24 this year, I like his chances of an increase in power, his HR/FB% could improve with a return to his launch angle and barrel % of last season as well as an age improvement in power. He will need to improve his numbers against lefties if he wants to take the next step. With Yordan returning to the Stros lineup and another year between them and The Scandal, I like Tucker’s spot in a potent lineup. I think Kyle will be a profitable player in 2021.

Woodruff 3.05/0.99 11.12 K/9 6.1% BB rate, .269 BABIP 3.30 SIERA, 3.29 FIP, 3.20 xFIP
Brandon is awesome. I could seriously just stop there. He is underrated and will likely provide profit when you draft him in 2021 because he is under appreciated. He has elite FB velocity – 97 MPH, he has five good pitches, he keeps the ball in the park and he has a great K rate. The Brewers have an excellent bullpen so he should have a better win/loss record in 2021. He will be 28 this season and the most innings he has thrown in The Bigs is 121, is this the reason he does not gather as much enthusiasm that his numbers should?

My TOP 50 players for 2021
1. Juan Soto
2. Acuña
3. Trout
4. Tatis, Jr.
5. Trey Turner
6. Betts
7. de Grom
8. Cole
9. Story
10. Freeman
11. Jose Ramirez
12. Bieber
13. Bryce Harper
14. Bauer
15. Machado
16. Yellich
17. DJ LeMahieu
18. Darvish
19. Mondesi
20. Kershaw
21. Lindor
22. Corey Seager
23. Bellinger
24. Buehler
25. Aaron Nola
26. Giolito
27. Scherzer
28. Arenado
29. Luis Castillo
30. Kyle Tucker
31. Abreu
32. K Maeda
33. A Rendon
34. X Bogaerts
35. Bregman
36. Eloy
37. L Robert
38. Ozzie Albies
39. Bo Bichette
40. Brandon Woodruff
41. M Ozuna
42. J Flaherty
43. Aaron Judge
44. Whit Merrifield
final six in no particular order – T Anderson, Devers, JT Realmuto, S Marte, Gallen, Glasnow.
 
2wiggs
      Leader
      ID: 04991311
      Wed, Mar 24, 2021, 18:38
wow- excellent write up. Heres to winning the lottery and being able to get on some fantasy baseball show :)
 
3holt
      ID: 491153264
      Thu, Mar 25, 2021, 04:04
Random observation. In Flaherty's defense, most of his ERA came in one game. 9 of the 22 runs he gave up in 3 innings against Milwaukee. Correct me if I'm wrong but he was the best pitcher in baseball after the ASB in 2019. That may not be 100% correct, I'm working off memory there but I know he won a lot of fantasy leagues that year.

Also, when Mondesi hits one of hot streaks he is pure fire and the best player in the game. Just gets hurt a lot.
 
4holt
      ID: 491153264
      Thu, Mar 25, 2021, 04:10
Found it. To finish up 2019 Flaherty had a 0.74 WHIP in 6 August starts and a 0.57 WHIP in 6 Sep/Oct starts. So sick. His second half numbers were 7-2, 0.91 era, 0.72 whip, 124K in 99.1 IP. What a run that was.
 
5Seattle Zen
      ID: 301361318
      Thu, Mar 25, 2021, 11:00
holt - Flaherty certainly was the hottest pitcher for the second half of 2019. Though I would argue that Ryu was had the best hot streak of 2019. His first 22 starts, more than just a half, he had a 1.45 ERA, a 0.93 WHIP 12 wins and 121 K. The top 40-50 pitchers are capable of putting together white hot stretches. My concerns with Flaherty last season was when you look under the hood you see that his fastball was crushed. The exit velo shows that guys were teeing off on his stuff, the heat maps show that he was leaving his pitches in the middle of the plate which lead to a 36% line drive rate. Sure, he gave up 9 earned to the Brewers in 3 innings but his 2020 was more concerning than just those three poor innings.
 
6holt
      ID: 491153264
      Thu, Mar 25, 2021, 11:49
As a Cardinals fan, hopefully that is just weird 2020 noise. Lack of focus, or maybe some guys can't play sports properly in an quiet empty stadium. Or, maybe hitters are better against him in empty stadiums. I have no idea, just throwing stuff out there so I can ignore weird stats from 2020.

Yeah Ryu had an insane 2019. I didn't have him on any teams unfortunately but I did stop to stare at his stats frequently.
 
7Seattle Zen
      ID: 301361318
      Thu, Mar 25, 2021, 12:13
I think any team would be ecstatic to have Flaherty on its staff - young and promising. Just don't know what to expect in 2021
 
8Seattle Zen
      ID: 46926512
      Tue, Oct 05, 2021, 13:30
Let's take a look back at my top 50 players and how they did according to ESPN's player rater for our league

My TOP 50 players for 2021
1. Juan Soto - 15.25 top bat, second overall
2. Acuña - 9.13 24th bat
3. Trout - 2.18
4. Tatis, Jr. - 13.81 tied for sixth bat and overall
5. Trey Turner - 14.55 4th bat
6. Betts - 7.33 44th bat
7. de Grom - 9.83
8. Cole - 10.46 11th pitcher
9. Story - 7.94 35th bat
10. Freeman - 11.13 11th bat
11. Jose Ramirez - 13.81 tied for sixth bat and overall
12. Bieber - 3.86
13. Bryce Harper - 14.67 third bat and overall
14. Bauer - 6.30
15. Machado - 8.88 26th bat
16. Yellich - 3.66
17. DJ LeMahieu - 2.71
18. Darvish - 5.56
19. Mondesi - 0.69
20. Kershaw - 6.04
21. Lindor - 3.58
22. Corey Seager - 5.26
23. Bellinger - NEGATIVE 3.83 LOLOLOL
24. Buehler - 12.74 second pitcher
25. Aaron Nola - 5.33
26. Giolito - 7.52
27. Scherzer - 13.23 Top pitcher
28. Arenado - 5.28
29. Luis Castillo - 3.30
30. Kyle Tucker - 10.28 15th bat
31. Abreu - 7.16
32. K Maeda - 1.04
33. A Rendon - -1.01
34. X Bogaerts - 7.72 36th bat
35. Bregman - 2.27
36. Eloy - -0.93
37. L Robert - 4.56
38. Ozzie Albies - 9.14 23rd bat
39. Bo Bichette - 12.00 9th bat
40. Brandon Woodruff - 10.15 13th pitcher
41. M Ozuna - -2.38
42. J Flaherty - 3.95
43. Aaron Judge - 9.94 18th bat
44. Whit Merrifield - 9.10 25th bat
final six in no particular order – T Anderson - 7.4 40th bat
Devers - 10.01 17th bat
JT Realmuto - 5.48
S Marte - 13.51 8th bat and overall
Gallen - 1.56
Glasnow - 5.05

Looking back at my write up, these players fell into four categories. First, players whom I was leery of and I was right. There were nine - T Bauer. HA! I told you he was a troll, maybe my best prediction of them all. Bellinger. Has anyone had a worse season than he just did? GOOD GOD! Lindor, awful. Yellich, the fourteenth season I have been down on him, I'm usually right. Flaherty, people counting on a bounceback were disappointed, I wasn't. Z Gallen, I wondered aloud why he was so hyped but even my skepticism didn't predict just how awful he was. Glasnow, my quote He could be lights out and then hurt like 2019. proved true. L Robert, didn't predict his injury but I was right to be careful.

Second, there were players whom I was leery of but ended up doing just fine. First, I was REALLY down on Bo Bichette but I am glad to say that I put those feelings aside and traded for him half way through the year. R Devers, the kid can crush and I was wrong in thinking he was a lazy bum. Still not likely to pay the asking price next year. Aaron Judge, well, he finally stayed healthy and crushed. Max Scherzer, I don't think anyone predicted he would be the top arm in all of baseball. So, that's nine duds I forecast versus four duds that were actually studs. Not bad at all.

Third, players whom I was bullish on and I was right. There are twelve of them. Freeman, B Harper, Machado, J Ramirez, J Soto, T Trey, T Anderson, X Boegarts, W Buehler, S Marte, K Tucker and B Woodruff. Fourth, I was bullish on these eleven guys but I was wrong. Y Darvish, M Trout, N Arenado, A Bregman, L Castillo, Eloy, LeMahieu, A Mondesi, M Ozuna, A Rendon, and C Seager.

There were some hilarious quotes up there: On A Rendon- Such consistency, about a safe a bet in the top 50 as you can find.
I was super bullish on M Ozuna. Somehow I ended up with zero shares of him on any of my teams, thank goodness! I was also very high on DJ LeMahieu and A Mondesi and avoided those disasters. I don't really think Arenado was a bust. He did have over 100 RBI. I don't regret drafting him, his OBP is poor and he doesn't steal bases but he isn't really a bust.

This was a fun exercise but I'm not sure I will do it again for 2022. Maybe if I get snowed in, we'll see.
 
9Tree
      ID: 161118314
      Tue, Oct 05, 2021, 14:36
This was a pretty cool project, and i applaud the depth. but man, did the injury bug hit a lot of those guys HARD.
 
10WG
      ID: 89402220
      Tue, Oct 05, 2021, 14:55
I missed this when it was initially posted, but want to echo Tree's praise... nice work! Looking forward to reading when I get some time.